Both a scroll saw and jigsaw are useful in making curved lines. While the first is designed for better precision, the latter does this less precisely but can be used for other things. There are certain situations where one is more preferable than the other.
Maybe you are not sure whether to buy a scroll saw or jigsaw. Not to worry, as this article will explain the differences and details of each one.
This includes the benefits and disadvantages of a scroll saw and jigsaw. Hopefully, you can then decide which is the better choice for you.
1. What is a scroll saw?
Let’s first understand what scroll saw really is, as it lies somewhere between a jigsaw and sewing machine. It is an electric or pedal-operated stationary device used to cut intricate curves in various materials.
A small and fine blade is anchored at the top and bottom that could rotate and cut through these materials.
The blade is mounted vertically and moves either up or down. As a scroll saw is stationary, you would move the material around the blade instead of moving the machine. Just like sewing a piece of clothing!
2. Scroll saw benefits
One of the most common reasons why DIYers love the scroll saw is its ability to cut intricate details. It is easy to make detailed and delicate cuts that are smooth and precise. Just carve along the pattern lines!
Not to mention that you can use a scroll saw to make pierce cuts, or cuts that start in the middle of the material.
It’s extremely easy to use and even children can operate it, thanks to its stationary point. The machine also operates quietly, which lets you work without making much noise.
However, arguably the best thing about it is that it produces very little dust! No more mess in the workshop.
Read also: How to Use a Scroll Saw
3. Scroll saw disadvantages
Unfortunately, while being stationary makes them stable and easy to use, this also makes them not portable. Unlike other handheld saws and power tools, you cannot transport this machine easily.
Another disadvantage of the scroll saw is that it performs best only with thinner woods. This means you may not be able to work on your thick materials.
- Make delicate and intricate cuts
- Easy to use
- Quiet operation
- Minimal dust
- Stationary device that is not portable
- Not ideal for thick materials
1. What is a jigsaw?
On the other hand, a jigsaw is a handheld saw that could come with or without a cord. The small, reciprocating blade is anchored at its top and can move downwards to cut into the material.
This power tool can be used to cut wood, steel, fiberglass and even drywall. This is quite a common option for homeowners or everyday hobby workers.
Mostly because it is quite safe to use and incredibly versatile. People usually use a jigsaw to cut both curved and straight lines, depending on what they need.
2. Jigsaw benefits
Unlike the larger and stationary scroll saw, you can actually whip up your jigsaw anytime anywhere! The great thing about handheld tools is that you can easily bring them around with you.
Jigsaws are also easy to use and inexpensive, so that even a child could safely unbox and use them
What makes woodworkers excited about jigsaws, however, is its versatility. You can use them to cut through various materials, from wood and plastic to metal and ceramic tiles alike.
Moreover, it is perfect for remodeling and demolition tasks, as well as other projects around the house!
3. Jigsaw disadvantages
Of course, there are some drawbacks from using a jigsaw instead of a scroll saw. The main thing is that jigsaws cannot handle detailed cuts as well.
The results will be much less clean, especially if the design is too tiny. Some have also found that using a jigsaw is a lot more messier too, so that might be something to consider.
- Easy to use
- Great for versatile cuts
- Less clean cuts
- Messy to use
At the end of the day, you should get the one that can best cater to your needs. The scroll saw is better for making intricate ornaments and tiny cuts, although it is more expensive to buy.
Meanwhile, the jigsaw is a cheap, versatile and portable tool to help you with most around-the-house projects and DIYs.